All the following players played for Barnet and Nuneaton Borough, but not for Nuneaton Town in it's current conception.
Kirk Stephens played for Barnet during the 1987/88 season scoring 2 goals. Earlier I his career, he played for Nuneaton Borough after being released by Coventry City.
Paul Culpin scored 3 goals in 5 games during Barnet's 1990/91 promotion season while on loan from Peterborough. He began his career at Nuneaton Borough scoring 131 goals in 150 games before joining Coventry City in 1985.
Frank Murphy was another member of the Barnet 1990/91 promotion season and he scored 44 goals in 122 matches for the Bees after signing from Kettering Town. He also had a spell at Nuneaton Borough.
Roy Clayton joined Barnet from Kettering Town in 1980 and scored 7 goals in 45 games for the Bees before moving to Nuneaton Borough. He later played for Corby Town and VS Rugby.
Greg Pearson had a spell on loan at Barnet from West Ham in 2004 and he scored 1 goal (at Gravesend) in 10 appearances. During the summer he joined Nuneaton Town from Grimsby.
Other players who played for both teams included, Everton Carr and Phil Sandercock